Award Compliance — Level 28/60 Margaret St, Sydney NSW 2000, Australia

Payroll compliance audit — confidential

Harbourview Café

Prepared by Award Compliance · Sydney NSW dataset · Sample edition

Headline finding

$11,460

in underpayment across 13 weeks — 15.1% of gross wages.

185 of 325 shifts (57%) and 8 of 8 employees were affected. At this run rate, the annualised exposure is approximately $45,800. Every employee was paid the same flat $32.00/hr; almost all of the underpayment comes from what a flat rate ignores — penalties, public holidays and overtime.

Audit period
13 weeks (1 Apr – 30 Jun 2026)
Employees reviewed
8 of 8
Shifts reviewed
325
Gross wages in period
$75,842

Findings by mechanism

Public holiday loading

22 shifts

$4,452

Casual and permanent staff paid their usual flat rate on public holidays (casual Level 2 award rate on a public holiday: $64.63/hr).

Sunday penalty

48 shifts

$3,555

Flat weekday rate paid on Sundays. Casual Level 2 Sunday rate is $45.24/hr — a flat $32.00 leaves ~$79 short per 6-hour shift.

Saturday penalty

52 shifts

$1,997

Saturday loading not applied to casual staff paid a flat rate.

Overtime (indicative)

18 employee-weeks

$1,339

Two full-time cooks regularly rostered 42.5 h/week at a flat rate. Overtime under the award: 150% for the first 2 hours on a weekday, 200% after that and on weekends.

Below base rate

45 shifts

$117

Marginal gap on weekday shifts (31 cents/hr on the flat rate vs the casual weekday minimum).

Note the last line. The base-rate check — the one an owner can do by hand against a pay guide — represents 1% of the total exposure. The four mechanisms above it, the ones no one checks manually, represent the other 99%.

Root causes — three, not a hundred

1. One flat rate for every day of the week

Staff are paid a “good rate” ($32.00/hr): comfortably above the weekday minimum for permanent staff, 31 cents under it for casuals — and well short of the Saturday, Sunday and public holiday minimums for everyone. The rate looks generous on ordinary days and falls short on the days that cost the most.

2. The Easter / Anzac cluster

Six NSW public holidays fell inside four weeks: Good Friday to Easter Monday (3–6 April), Anzac Day (Saturday 25 April) and the additional Monday (27 April) — then the King’s Birthday on 8 June. A casual Level 2 on a public holiday must be paid $64.63/hr; everyone worked those days at their usual rate. Public holidays account for $4,452 — 39% of the total finding.

3. Overtime treated like salaried work

The two full-time cooks work 42.5 hours most weeks at a flat rate. Hours beyond 38 a week are overtime: 150% for the first 2 hours on a weekday, 200% after that and on weekends. Willingness to work the hours doesn’t change the rate they must be paid at.

One detail worth noticing: the part-time employee who was paid correctly the rest of the quarter still appears once — Easter Monday, $181 short. Compliance is a shift-by-shift property, not a person-by-person one.

Recommended actions, in order

  1. 1.Fix the public holiday configuration in your payroll software before the next holiday (largest single mechanism).
  2. 2.Introduce day-based rates for casual staff (weekday / Saturday / Sunday) instead of one flat rate.
  3. 3.Pay the full-time cooks award overtime, or bring their rosters back to 38 hours a week.
  4. 4.Decide on back-payment with your accountant. Finding and fixing errors promptly is one of the things the Fair Work Ombudsman’s Voluntary Small Business Wage Compliance Code looks at.
  5. 5.Re-check after 1 July — the Annual Wage Review changes award rates from the first full pay period on or after 1 July.

Method & limitations

Findings are based on the data supplied and on rates verified against the consolidated award text at awards.fairwork.gov.au. Evening and night work loading (Monday to Friday: 7pm–midnight and midnight–7am under this award), overtime for both casual and permanent employees, shifts on your state’s official public holidays (2020–2026), and the tool and first aid allowances (at the amount in force each week; the tool allowance from February 2021) are included as roster-based estimates. Junior rates by age, including the rule that a junior employed to serve alcohol is paid the adult rate, apply to the employees you identify as juniors, at the award percentage of the adult rate in force for each pay period. This analysis does not model apprentice or junior-office rates, other allowances (meal, laundry, leading hand), annualised salary arrangements, or regional public holidays observed only in some areas — where these apply, the true exposure is likely higher, not lower. This report states that discrepancies were, or were not, identified in the data supplied; it is not a declaration of compliance, and it is not legal, accounting or tax advice — the full scope is set out in our Terms of service.